PRE2017 3 Groep3

Subject

The subject for this project was chosen to be: Motion planning algorithm for window cleaning robots.

Objectives

• Literature study of current window cleaning robots and USE aspects regarding window cleaning robots.
• To develop an efficient cleaning algorithm that cleans a window which satisfies certain requirements on cleaning speed, water consumption, energy consumption.

Final Products

The final products of this project is a NetLogo model of a window clean robot on a dirty window surface. Within this model, it will be possible to perform the process of cleaning the window with regard to several different motion planning algorithms that will be designed during this project. The data output from this model can then be analyzed and compared to find a better and the best performing algorithm with respect to the current motion planning of these robots.

All information about the project found on the WIKI page is also orderly put together in the form of a technological report about the chosen subject.

The NetLogo model:
File:0LAUK0 Motion Planning Model Group 3 (all algorithms).zip

Report group 3-Motion planning algorithm for window-cleaning robots:
File:0LAUK0 Group 03 Report.pdf

Introduction

Every year there are major innovations in the field of technology. Self-driving cars, reusable rockets and even face-recognition abilities of current smart-phones are some examples. Not all innovations, however, get the same amount of attention and some are thus less widely known. This report focuses on the improvement of a small and less impact full technological piece of equipment, namely the window cleaning robot. Window cleaning robots are currently built for two main application domains, domestic use and professional use on big skyscrapers or flats. The advancements in the capabilities of these window cleaning robots are still in the early stages. Nevertheless, there is already a range of window cleaning robots available on the market, differing in size and performance. However, the existing window cleaning robots for domestic use have all a major shortcoming in common: their movement is based on a simple, inefficient motion planning. This is mainly due to the thought of minimal gain and the aim for simplicity. Therefore, an optimized motion planning algorithm is developed in this project. This optimized algorithm will be applicable to the smaller sized window cleaning robots that are used for domestic applications. The design question is:

How should the main, currently used a motion-planning algorithm for small sized window cleaning robots for domestic use be improved such that it is more efficient in terms of cleaning speed, energy consumption, and water consumption?

The answer to this question will be relevant for the users, window cleaning companies, since they can buy a set of window cleaning robots operating on this algorithm to improve their services and increase their revenue as an enterprise. Besides that, the developed algorithm will help the customers through better scheduling and faster clean ups and help society through advancement of planning-algorithms which may spark further improvements on the algorithms of motion planning robots.

The main scenario for which the motion planning is designed is a small window cleaning company that has multiple cleaning robots in its possession, with one employee who can move the cleaning robots from one window to another, allowing him to clean multiple windows simultaneously, thereby reducing the time it takes to clean all the windows in the building and reducing labor cost.

This report consists of six chapters, starting with a literature study on the capabilities of current window cleaning robots and their motion planning algorithms. Followed by a systematic design process, including approach, user requirements, design choices, concepts, assumptions, robot specifications and a simulation model. In this model, the performance of two innovative algorithms will be tested and compared to the current approach listed in the literature study. The results from the model will subsequently be thoroughly evaluated. In the end, a well-funded conclusion will be given.

State of the Art

In order to notably contribute to any technological development, it is necessary to know the current state of that development. This section summarizes, therefore, a literature study performed on scientific articles regarding the subject of motion planning algorithms of window cleaning robots, specifications of existing window cleaning robots, the potential user needs for window cleaning robots and expectations of window cleaning robots. First, it is explained what the existing window cleaning robots are capable of. Subsequently, it is explained why their motion planning algorithms are not optimal.

A summary of the information found in the literature study can be found here:

State of the Art
Also, the list below gives an overview of the summaries of the articles which have been studied. The articles are divided into subcategories.

Article summaries literature study

Design Process

Approach

Prior to the development of the model, a literature study on currently available window cleaning robots is performed. This literature study was actually the motivation to design an efficient motion planning algorithm for window cleaning robots.

The design process of the motion planning algorithm is divided into the following steps:

1. Analysis of the user and user requirements, preferences and constraints
2. Conceptualization
3. Choosing the best solution
4. Modeling the motion planning algorithm by means of NetLogo
5. Refine the motion planning algorithm
6. Evaluation of the obtained results

After each step the solutions or results are fed back to the requirements, preferences and constraints defined in step 1. This makes sure that the user stays central during the whole design process and undesirable results are prohibited.

Users

As mentioned in the introduction, window cleaning companies are considered during this project. This makes the window washing companies the primary users in the design process. They can use window cleaning robots to improve their services. The considered scenario is that these companies are hired by private individuals (secondary users) to clean the windows of their houses or buildings. It is assumed that window cleaning companies own multiple of these robots that can be deployed on different windows and can so clean the windows simultaneously. The faster, cheaper and more efficient these robots can accomplish this, the more profit the company can make since the windows of more houses can be cleaned in the same time span. A major factor in accomplishing this purpose would be a motion planning algorithm that determines how to clean the windows of a house in a highly efficient way.
In order to develop such a motion planning algorithm, requirements, preferences, and constraints should be made explicit. If one considers the view of the primary and secondary users, the window washing companies and private individuals respectively, the following requirements, preferences, and constraints could be distinguished.

Which can be found here:

Requirements, preferences, and constraints

Design Choices

Before starting the modeling, an important choice needed to be made in order to construct a model of the motion planning. This considers the choice of the program that is used for modeling this algorithm. The program that was eventually chosen is NetLogo. There are several reasons for this particular choice of program. An important reason is that NetLogo makes it easy to create graphical output alongside the numerical simulation of the motion planning algorithm. This enables the visualization of the window cleaning robot using the programmed motion planning algorithm to clean a window. The visualization reduces the risk of incorrect programming of the movement patterns. Additionally, in NetLogo, there is a predefined relation between agents, the so-called turtles, and the square sections of the underground over which they move, the so-called patches. This relation is of course particularly useful for modeling the cleaning of the window (the patches) by the robot (the agent) and the checking of the cleanliness of a section of the window by the robot. NetLogo also has the ability to create sliders for some of the parameters of the model.

This makes it easy to test the motion planning algorithm in different environments (e.g. different dirt distributions or different window sizes). Furthermore, NetLogo is relatively easy to program and its program language is already known by the members of the group from a previous course.

Another choice was made about prototyping. At first there was the intention to create a real physical prototype by making use of a LEGO Mindstorms robot. Unfortunately, this was not viable. Making a robot from LEGO that moves in a programmable pattern on a flat surface is possible, but the problem lies with the color sensor that would be used to detect dirty places. Most current window cleaning robots have multiple dirt sensors in a line that detect whether dirt passes under that line. The LEGO Mindstorms robot would only have one color sensor, which means that it would constantly have to move the sensor perpendicular to the direction the vehicle is moving in order to check for dirt. This would result in a robot that moves at such a slow pace that practical experiments would be infeasible. Because of this, it was decided to stick to just the development of the model.

Planning, milestones & deliverables

Week	Goal	Milestones	Deliverables
1	Finish work plan Finish literature study and SotA	Finished literature study and SotA	Work plan Summaries of articles
2	Confirm definitive subject and project goal Adapt the project planning	Clear and measurable project goal	Project planning
3	Divide the possible approaches to window-cleaning algorithms, and research them Start the basis of the algorithm/ simulation Precisely anylise users and user needs Create a list of precise measurables and ways to achieve these numbers Research potential simulation programs and get handy with the coding skills needed	Clear vision of the project to all members and a definitive goal and approach to the problem	Sheet of potential algorithms with their pro and cons Definitive program in which model simulations will be done
4	Check whether algorithm satisfies the requirements, preferences, and constraints of the group, adapt the algorithm accordingly. Choose a definitive algorithm approach and start the programming of the simulation	Definitive algorithm which can be simulated and results in the measurables wanted. (close to completion simulation)	Finished or close to finished programmed model simulation
5	Analysis of the simulation; expected results, satisfying results? Further improvements to the algorithm. Start writing report	Finished and analyzed model.	Measurables compared to expectations.
6	Start report work; divide chapters into; introduction, theory, algorithm, simulation, results, conclusion, future improvements and appendices.	Finished report	Correct report and simulation
7	Buffer time - finish report.

Task division

Week	What?	Who?
1	Finish work plan Finish literature study and SotA (Everybody searches 5 articles, reads them and summarizes them)	Everybody together Everybody
2	Finish analysis of the user and user needs Edit project planning and update wiki with references Finish SotA	Lars, Kylian Ibrahim, Jorick Ezra
3	Specify the model design Program a basic window in Netlogo Research implementation of water usage Research implementation of energy usage Coaching questions + update planning and division of tasks on wiki	Kylian Lars Ibrahim Ezra Jorick
4	Start modeling the motion planning of the robot into Netlogo Research turning paths and times for robot Write report about the first half of the project Specifically describe the robots attributes and functions	Jorick, Kylian Ezra Lars, Ibrahim Lars, Ibrahim
5	Further programme the netlogo behaviour Programme a better dirt distribution Write about algortihm Update state of the art Mathematics and explanations behind turning behaviour in report Fix contradicting statements in report How to incorperate weight of the robot into model Summeries the possible factors in which time savings can be had	Lars, Kylian Kylian Lars Ibrahim Ezra Jorick Jorick, Ibrahim Jorick, Ibrahim
6	Finish model Compare final results from model with controll values Finish report	Lars, Kylian Jorick, Ibrahim Everybody
7	Finish report	Group work

Work on the model

Setup of the model

For the setup of the motion planning algorithm (the concept, assumptions and simplification, etc.), we would like to refer to the report, see the section below.

Current state of the model
The following things are already modeled:

• Window is programmed on which a random dirt distribution appears (also with clusters dirt).
• The robot is modeled in such a way that it represents reality.
• The robot can move
• The robot is able to clean the whole window by doing a standard zigzag motion.
• Rotation times that are analytically determined (video of a possible movement pattern + movements) are implemented in the model.

The model looks currently as follows:

The following things should still be implemented:

• Making the robot able to clean windows with heights that are not a multiple of the robot dimensions.
• Implementing that short zigzag motions should be performed when the robot moves over persistent spots of dirt.

Work on the report

The current state of the report can be seen by using the following link: [1].report

Coaching Questions

Coaching Questions Group 3

The links below refer to pages with the coaching questions of each week.

• Week 1: Coaching Questions
• Week 2: Coaching Questions
• Week 3: Coaching Questions
• Week 4: Coaching Questions
• Week 5: Coaching Questions
• Week 6: Coaching Questions
• Week 7: Coaching Questions

References

[1] Akinfiev,T. Armada,M. & Nabulshi,S. (2009). Climbing cleaning robot for vertical surfaces. Industrial Robot: An International Journal, Vol. 36 Issue: 4 pp.352-357.
[2] Barbut,O. (2008). Window Cleaning Robot ASME Design Competition. Department of Mechanical Engineering Toronto.
[3] Choi,Y. & Jung,K. (2011 November 26). WINDORO: The World's First Commercialized Window Cleaning Robot for Domestic Use. Pohang Institute of Intelligent Robotics Korea.
[4]Choi,Y-H. Lee,J-Y. Lee,J-D. & Lee,K-E. (2012 November 29).SMART WINDORO V1.0: Smart Window Cleaning Robot. Korea Institute of Robot & Convergence.
[5] Chu,B. Jung,K. Han,C. & Hong,D.(2010 August). A Survey of Climbing Robots: Locomotion and Adhesion. Department of Mechanical Engineering South Korea.
[6] Galceran,E. & Carreras,M.(2013 August 5). A survey on coverage path planning for robotics. University of Girona Spain.
[7] Gandhinathan, R. & Ambigai, R. (2016). Design and Kinematic Analysis of Tethered Guiding Vehicle (TGV) for façade window cleaning. Department of Mechanical Engineering India.
[8] Gerstmayr-Hillen,L et al. (2013 January 17). Dense topological maps and partial pose estimation for visual control of autonomous cleaning robot. Computer Engineering Group , Faculty of Technology Germany.
[9] Imoaka,N. Roh,S. Yusuke,N. & Hirose,S. (2010 October 22). SkyScraper-I: Tethered Whole Windows Cleaning Robot. Design of Moving Mechanisms and Preliminary Experiments Taiwan.
[10] Jiang,J. Zhang,Y. & Zhang,S. (2014).Implementation of glass-curtain-wall cleaning robot driven by double flexible rope. Industrial Robot: an International Journal, Vol.41 Issue: 5 pp.429-438.
[11] Katsuki,Y. Ikeda,T. & Yamamoto,M. (2011 September 30). Development of a High Efficiency and High reliable Glass Cleaning Robot with a Dirt Detect Sensor.
[12] Lee,J. Choi,Y. & Lee,J. (2013 November 2). Calculation of Optimal Magnetic Force for Automatic Control Magnetic Force of the Window Cleaning Robot. Korea Institute of Robot and Convergence Korea.
[13] Lee,S. Kang,M. & Han,C. (2012 December). Sensor Based Motion Planning and Estimation of High-rise Building Façade Maintenance Robot. Department of Mechatronics Engineering South Korea.
[14] Leidner,D. & Beetz,M. (2016 November 17). Inferring the Effects of Wiping Motions based on Haptic Perception.
[15] Lui,J. Tanaka,K. Bao,L M. & Yamaura,I.(2005 October 3).Analytic modeling of suction cups used for window-cleaning robots. Department of Functional Machinery and Mechanics Japan.
[16] Liu,J. Jiang,H. Li,Z. & Hu,H. (2009). A Small Window-Cleaning Robot for Domestic Use. Jiangnan University China.
[17] Liu, J. et al. (2011 May 9). A Gecko Inspired Fluid Driven Climbing Robot. Institute Of Mechatronic Control Engineering Zhejiang University.
[18] Lupetti,M L. Rosa,S. & Ermacora,G. From a Robotic Vacuum Cleaner to a Robot Companion: Acceptance and Engagement in Domestic Environments.
[19] Moon,S M. Shin,C Y. Huh,J. Won,K. & Hong,D. (2015 January). Window Cleaning System with Water Circulation for Building Façade Maintenance Robot and Its Efficiency Analysis. School of Mechanical Engineering South Korea.
[20] Nguyen,D. & Shimada,A. (2013). A Path Motion Planning For Humanoid Climbing Robot. Shibuara Institute of Technology Japan.
[21] Nishi,A. A wall climbing robot for inspection use. Miyazaki University Japan.
[22] Palleja,T. Transanchez,M. Teixido,M. & Palacin,J. (2009 August 11). Modeling floor-cleaning coverage performance of some domestic mobile robots in a reduced scenario. Department of Computer Science Spain.
[23] Seo,K. Cho,S. Kim,T. Kim,H S. & Kim, J. (2013 August 15). Design and stability analysis of a novel wall-climbing robotic platform (ROPE RIDE). Mechanism and Machine Theory pp.189-208.
[24] Zanele,G N M. (2011 June). Motion Planning Algorithms for Autonomous Robots in Static and Dynamic Environments. University of Johannesburg.
[25] Zhou,Q. & Li,X. (2016). Experimental comparison of drag-wiper and roller-wiper glass-cleaning robots. Industrial Robot: An International Journal, Vol.43 Issue:4, pp409-420.