PRE2019 3 Group5
Group members
| Name | Student ID | Department |
|---|---|---|
| Ana Maria Risnoveanu | 1230444 | Electrical Engineering |
| Stacey Elshove | 1279998 | Psychology and Technology |
| Petru Radulescu | 1371320 | Psychology and Technology |
| Yiqin Hou | 1281135 | Electrical Engineering |
| Tobias Hilpert | 1281070 | Chemical Engineering |
Problem Statement
Today the technology for recycling already exists and is put to use in most first world countries, but at times it can be inefficient because of mistakes made by all of us when throwing the trash, either unwillingly or because of our ignorance. So to mitigate this and help create a better planet for the future generation, we have come up with the idea of a smart trash can, that will use a huge array of sensors and cameras to determine whether the waste should go in the glass, plastic or paper bin. This product will be small enough to fit in our homes and, in the future, it could be upscaled to service a full residence, like a block of flats.
Objectives
- Design an affordable smart trashcan that fits into our homes.
- Use machine learning and AI to sort the trash into their corresponding compartment.
- Find suitable technologies to achieve this.
USE Aspects
User
The user group we wish to target is households, we would like to improve recycling at the source and make it easier for users. To better understand the users' needs, a survey is currently being carried out. Survey More time needed to complete the survey, we will close the survey on Wednesday (19 February 2020) this week and start data analysis.
Society
Automatizing recycling will shift the topic from a widely recognized theme to an issue to be solved by experts. Recycling campaigns will likely get far less attention than they do now and did in the recent past. This might slightly counteract the intended effect of increasing recycling. These effects seem unlikely to outweigh the advantages gained in the efficiency of sorting, however. There will also be a shift of who holds the responsibility for recycling. This responsibility is currently largely held by the consumer who is expected to throw garbage into the designated bins. If this process is largely automated the responsibility will either be carried by a few enterprises or, shared among society as a whole if the adoption of smart cans is facilitated through government owned utilities.
Enterprise
Recycling firms are struggling to be profitable in large part due to expensive and inefficient separation of waste feed-streams. An automated bin will judge much more accurately which products are likely to be recyclable than the average consumer. This improved recycling prior to waste collection would drastically lower the cost of recycling and increase profitability of these plants, therefore encouraging new investments into such businesses. The increase of separated waste arriving at recycling plants rather than landfills will also allow for these plants to invoke the economics of scaling up to further increase profitability, making such businesses even more attractive. It thus likely that widely accessible smart bins will grow the recycling industry.
Task distribution
Week1
| Name[total hours of work] | Tasks and hours |
|---|---|
| Ana Maria Risnoveanu [8h] | learn wikitext[1h], Material sensors [5h]
[1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6], Approach-Milestones-Deliverables [1h], look over internet for other ideas [1h] |
| Stacey Elshove[10.5h] | learn wikitext[2h], Reasons why[7][8]and summary[4h], What already exists[9][7][10] and summary[4.5h] |
| Petru Radulescu[6h] | Leran wikitext[2h]; Objectives[1h]; Problem statement[1h]; Sorting systems[2h]... |
| Yiqin Hou[13h] | Papers about X-ray imaging[11][12][13][14]/Object recognition[15] searched and studied[7h]; summary of X-ray and coputer vision[2h]; Learn wikitext and make template for the group wiki[3.5h]; User aspect[0.5h] |
| Tobias Hilpert[14h] | Literature study into waste sorting[4h], Research into Infrared spectroscopy[8h], Learned wikitext[2h], Wrote Enterprise and Society aspect[] |
Week2
Subgroups
User survey form: Ana Maria Risnoveanu, Stacey Elshove, Yiqin Hou.
Recycling center: Petru Radulescu, Tobias Hilpert.
| Name[total hours of work] | Tasks and hours |
|---|---|
| Ana Maria Risnoveanu [h] | Two group meetings[3h] |
| Stacey Elshove[6h] | Two group meetings[3h], Prepare questions, finalize survey and distribute survey[1.5h], learn wikitext- links within a page and to external pages and add links[0.5h], edit wiki-User, Data analysis [1h] |
| Petru Radulescu[8h] | Two group meeting[3h], How the Dutch recycle[4], editing wiki[1h] |
| Yiqin Hou[8.5h] | Two group meetings[3h], Prepare quetions and distribute the user form[1h], edit wiki[0.5h]，think and sketch possible bin designs (the draft will not be uploaded to Wiki)[3h] |
| Tobias Hilpert[h] | Two group meetings[3h] |
Week2
| Name[total hours of work] | Tasks and hours |
|---|---|
| Ana Maria Risnoveanu [h] | Two group meetings[h] |
| Stacey Elshove[6h] | Two group meetings[h], |
| Petru Radulescu[8h] | Two group meeting[h], |
| Yiqin Hou[8.5h] | Two group meetings[h], General plan made, possible problems or hazards listed[1h] |
| Tobias Hilpert[h] | Two group meetings[h] |
SotA
Reasons why
Too much rubbish
Nowadays there is an over load in rubbish in cities and in rubbish dumps, he main reason for this is that there are many recyclable materials that just get throw away in the normal rubbish. Having smart bins will help reduce this waste and the resources we use to make produces. Sharma and Singha, [7] found that the pile up of rubbish is leading to many diseases and came up up with a solution about a Smart Bin that will alert the collector when the bin is full and they will come a collect it. This will prevent rubbish over load for example, rubbish falling out of bins or piling up next to them because they are full. However this is just a start to our problem as this still does not solve the recycling issue, this is dealt with in the next section.
Easy to recycle
The best way to get people to do things is to make it easy for them to do it. When it is easy to do something people are more inclined to do it than when they would have to put lots of effort in for example to have to take their separate plastics bag to the supermarket to recycle it when they could just add it to the normal rubbish.
Lack of knowledge
Thomas etal, found that many people are unaware of what happens after they throw something away, or the benefits of recycling[8]. Creating more awareness will cause people to understand what their actions will lead to and hopefully impact the way they behave.
Fun to recycle
When something is fun to do as when it easy to do people are more inclined to do it. This can be seen in the Efteling in the Netherlands, they have paper bins which are shaped like people who have their mouth open. People can through paper into their mouths and then they are thanked for recycling (feeding them). This make people more inclined to recycle as now it is fun to throw the paper into his mouth and they also receive positive feedback.
What already exists
Bin e is a smart bin that sorts anything you throw away[9] . It sorts the items into plastic, glass, paper and metal. This bin is only for recyclable materials thus people still have to put some thought into whether they can recycle it or not.
As mentioned above the Smart bin[7], which informs the collectors when it is full. The bin uses Ultrasonic sensors to determine how full the bin is.
How the Dutch recycle
There is a curbside collection service that collects: [16]
- Biodegradable waste in the green bins (almost all cities)
- Paper in yellow bins (almost all cities)
- Plastics in blue bins (major cities)
- Household chemicals, batteries in red bins (most cities)
- Clothing in green clothing containers (most cities)
For example, the cities of Eindhoven, Valkenswaart and Geldrop-Mierlo employ the company “Cure Afvalbeheer” to collect refuse and waste paper and recycle it into new products. Cure takes care of the collection of waste paper and cardboard, plastics, bulky household waste, glass and chemical waste.[17]
On the collection of recyclable waste: [18]
What paper can be recycled:
- Newspaper and fliers
- Copying, writing, drawing paper
- Envelopes
- Gift-wraps
- Egg boxes
- Paper bags and cardboard boxes
- Cardboard and paper packaging
What plastics can be recycled:
- Plastic bags and bread-, pasta and rice bags
- Wraps from magazines and advertising materials
- Plastic trays
- Yoghurt, cream and ice cream pots
- Plastic lids from jars
- Plastic bottles (from drinks, cooking products and sanitary products)
- Shampoo, shower gel, hand soap and bath foam bottles and similar
What glass can be recycled:
- Glass packaging of beverages
- Glassware of food (jars)
- Glass packaging of cosmetics
- Glass packaging of medicines
- Glass deodorant rollers
- Perfume bottles
What textile can be recycled:
- Clothing
- Bath towels
- Sheets, blankets
- Kitchen textiles
- Curtains
- Shoes (paired together)
- Bags, belts and scarves
What chemical waste can be recycled:
- Batteries, low-energy light bulbs, strip lights, liquid drain cleaner, lamp oil, kerosene, pesticides/ herbicides/insecticides
- Medicines, mercury thermometers, injection needles
- Paint, varnish, stain and wood preservation agents, products used when painting such as turpentine, thinner, paint stripper, paintbrush cleaner, paintbrush softener and benzene, mercury switches
The percentage of different wastes collected in the Netherlands: [19]
Detection
X-ray
Inspired by security machines, X-ray imaging could be a usefull tool in detcting the type of rubbish. X-ray imaging [13]makes use of the property of X-ray that it attenuates differently accorss difderent materials. For example metal atoms and ions attenuate more X-ray than normal organic tissue, such as fat and protein. Some new X-ray imaging techniques could even determine the chemical structures that form within the materials[14]. With such techiniques and some morden X-ray imaging detectors [12], the bin can distinguish materials much more accurate than using normal X-ray imaging. It is also possible to distinguish different types of plastics with X-ray imaging[11], which further increases the recycling sorting process.
Despite its reliable performance in detecting metal and different kinds of organic materials, an X-ray imaging system is too expensive to implement in a household trash bin. Even the cheapest X-ray tubes cost $100 to $500 each, let alone the detectors, power supply and other systems.
Computer vision and image processing
An alternative could be object recognition, by simply mounting a camera in the container and train an AI system to recognize different types of wastes. With the technique of using discriminative parts[15], the system could be even more precise. For example, it can distinguish the words on the package of the waste. Computer vison could be implemented together with other techniuqes like infrared spectroscopy, to increase overall effectiveness.
Infrared Spectroscopy
Infrared spectroscopy can be classified into different categories based on the wavelengths used. This detection method is both cheap and fast enough for practical applications in waste sorting. Near Infrared (NIR, wavelength 1-1.7µm) Spectroscopy is already deployed for uses in plastic separation. NIR has the ability to excite overtones of molecular vibrations and therefore can give information on the chemical composition of the sample. [20] NIR spectroscopy can also be used for different kinds of waste, such as construction debris [21]. There are clear limitations when analysing black and coloured samples though, as their reflectivity in the NIR spectrum is too low to allow for signal-to-noise ratios high enough for proper identification. To overcome this difficulty NIR spectroscopy can be enhanced with longer wavelengths. It has been shown that combining NIR with Midwave Infrared (MWIR, wavelength 3-12µm) significantly improves the performance of detectors for black and opaque products. [22] This can be extended to multiple spectra in hyperspectral imaging techniques, which probe a wide range of wavelengths even in the visible spectrum for material identification. These systems have also been shown to work at the speeds which would be needed for practical applications. [23] FTIR spectrometers are simple enough devices that handheld versions with sensitivities good enough to separate materials exist. [24].
Available sensors
There are several sensors available on the market: electro-mechanical, pneumatic, magnetic, inductive, capacitive, photoelectric, ultrasonic. The electromechanical sensor only shows how resistive an object is, which might be important but not sufficient here since two different objects could output the same value [1]. The same is the case with a pneumatic sensor, which just differs in the way it is built [2]. The magnetic sensors are of no use since there is no magnetic field created by rubbish [3]. On the other hand, although it also uses an induced magnetic field, the inductive sensor (also known as inductive proximity sensors) may prove successful in the detection of metallic materials. Unfortunately, domestic trash mostly includes other types of materials and aluminium cans, for instance, are usually recycled in waste. Then, there is little difference between the applications of inductive and capacitive sensors [5] and spending time in choosing between them will only be useful if the team decides on the categories of rubbish. A photoelectric sensor is another proximity sensor, which can only be used to check the absence of an object which leads to the last option on the list: ultrasonic sensors. Although these sensors cannot detect different types of materials, they do offer more information: the distance to an object or the speed of the object; they are reliable and can be used in many applications [6]. Some models of ultrasonic sensors come with detection of some aspects of the material (softness, colour) and therefore they are the best choice among simple and cheap detection methods. In order to know if they are a suitable choice, we must set the desired sensitivity of our system and check the limitations of different ultrasonic sensors.
Sorting systems
For sorting the trash itself the use of a conveyor type mechanism could be employed[25], such as a roller cylinder system that moves to create the right path to the corresponding bin for the trash.
Data analysis
Planning
The data analysis will be done on the program Stata. First the data will be checked and cleaned. One of the questions (Why is it difficult/easy to recycle?) will need to be analysed qualitatively, the rest can be analysed quantitatively. A factor analysis could be run on the data to help determine what is best for all the users needs.
Summary
The summary shown on the Google survey so far shows, that most people do want a smart bin. It is almost 50/50 that feel sorting their waste takes too much time or effort, this is shows that their is a need for this Smart bin. Around 70% of people would like all their waste collected and around 65% of people are willing to pay extra to have all their waste collected from this is could be said that people prefer when things are easy or done for them. Currently only 65% recycle glass and 23% recycle metal, this can show that there is a need for our Smart bin because around 70% of people do think that recycling is important which means they want to recycle but something is holding them back. From the question ,Why is it difficult/easy to recycle?, it can be seen that many people struggle to recycle because it is difficult to find or take it to the bins. If our smart bin would be implemented in many homes maybe more services would be provided to collect these recyclables because of the money that is saved from having to sort waste, this is something that would still need to be researched and investigated.
Approach
Solving one of the recycling problem aspects has a difficult set of objectives: first, the team must evaluate if a smart trash can is a suitable solution or if there are easier ways; the implementation is next in line. Our goal is to first design the bin with: all the necessary instructions, design of the smaller components, draw the circuits, write the code; everything necessary to build the smart bin if we had the resources.
Milestones
A certain milestone of the problem is finding a suitable way, preferably non-contact, to detect the trash that is put inside the bin; choosing the method depends on dividing the type of trash in the right categories, setting certain features of trash that the bin must detect. Next, the method must ensure it takes little time such that the bin can cope with high demand. Another milestone would be to make the bin robust to deviations from the model (it can happen that 2 types of trash are scanned together or it can happen that the queue of trash to be sorted becomes too long). The biggest milestone of the project is to actually finish the development (on paper) at the end of the 2 months.
| Week number | Tasks |
|---|---|
| Week1 | Background study |
| Week2 | User survey and factory study |
| Week3 | Preliminary design, make specifications of the product, study on sensors |
| Week4 | Design and make model, chose sensors, decide which part to focus on |
| Week5 | Second survey for feedbacks |
| Week6 | Test sensors/actuators and mount to the bin (if applicable) |
| Week7 | Validation of the design, analyze limitations and prepare for presentation |
Deliverables
The output of the project should be a full description, including the methods (such as pseudocode) for implementing the idea. The description should ensure that anyone who will read it, follow the steps and buy the necessary parts can build the smart trash bin. This might change due to the complexity of the project to simply finding the right method to sort the trash by categories.
Development
Hazards
Sketching
References
- ↑ 1.0 1.1 Ilene J. Bush-Vishniac, Eletromechanical Sensors and Actuators, Date accesed: 2020-02-09 www.parker.com › LPCE › function-fittings .
- ↑ 2.0 2.1 Pneumatic Sensor fittings Datasheet, (Springer, 1999).
- ↑ 3.0 3.1 Y Shigeta, S Hayano, Y Saito, Magnetic sensor signal Analysis, (International Journal of Electromagnetics and Mechanics, 2001/2002).
- ↑ 5 reasons to choose Induction over Hall Effect sensors, Date accesed: 2020-02-09 https://www.gillsc.com/newsitem/45/5-reasons-choose-induction-over-hall-effect-sensors.
- ↑ 5.0 5.1 Darran Kreit, Inductive verses Capacitive sensors, (Elsevier, 2013).
- ↑ 6.0 6.1 K Nakamura, Ultrasonic transducers : materials and design for sensors, actuators and medical applications, Part 3,
- ↑ 7.0 7.1 7.2 7.3 Sharma, N., Singha, N., & Dutta, T. (2015). "Smart Bin Implementation for Smart Cities". http://www.ijser.org. 5. Published: International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research, 6(9).Date accessed: 2020-02-08.
- ↑ 8.0 8.1 Thomas, C., Slater, R., Leaman, J., & Downing, P. (n.d.)." What Makes People Recycle? An Evaluation of Attitudes and Behaviour in London Western Riverside. 11. Date accessed: 2020-02-09.
- ↑ 9.0 9.1 Roberts, F. (2017)."Smart bin from Polish start-up Bin-e set to sort UK recycling problems.https://internetofbusiness.com/smart-bin-bin-e-recycling/. Date accessed: 2020-02-05.
- ↑ 10.0 10.1 Ramson, S. R. J., & Moni, D. J. (2017)." Wireless sensor networks based smart bin.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compeleceng.2016.11.030. 17: 337-353. Date accessed: 2020-02-08.
- ↑ 11.0 11.1 Peco-InspX. Detecting Plastics with X-Ray Inspection Systems. Date accessed: 2020-02-05. https://www.peco-inspx.com/blog/x-ray-detectable-plastics/
- ↑ 12.0 12.1 Sol M. Gruner.(2012). "X-ray imaging detectors" https://physicstoday.scitation.org/doi/10.1063/PT.3.1819 Pulisher: American Institute of Physics. Date accessed: 2020-02-06
- ↑ 13.0 13.1 Mary E.Coles. (1999). "8. X-Ray Imaging". https://doi.org/10.1016/S0076-695X(08)60419-6 . 35: 301-336. Date accessed: 2020-02-08.
- ↑ 14.0 14.1 Schroer, Christian G. (2011). "X-ray imaging: The chemistry inside". Nature. 476: 159-160. https://www-nature-com.dianus.libr.tue.nl/articles/476159a Date accessed: 2020-02-06
- ↑ 15.0 15.1 Liu, Ying-Ho; Lee, Anthony J.T.; Chang, Fu. (2012). "Object recognition using discriminative parts". Computer Vision and Image Understanding. 116: 854-867.
- ↑ ,https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Recyc,ling_in_the_Netherlands , Recycling in the Netherlands, Date accessed: 2020-02-14.
- ↑ ,https://www.eindhoven.nl/en/city-and-living/living/waste-recycling, WASTE & RECYCLING, Date accessed: 2020-02-15.
- ↑ ,https://www.cure-afvalbeheer.nl/en , Cure Afvalbeheer, Date accessed: 2020-02-15.
- ↑ , Maarten Goorhuis, Pieter Reus, Ellen Nieuwenhuis, Natascha Spanbroek, Mario Sol, Jørgen van Rijn,(2012) https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0734242X12455089 , New developments in waste management in the Netherlands, Date accessed: 2020-02-15.
- ↑ D M Scott 1995 Meas. Sci. Technol. 6 156 ‘A two-colour near-infrared sensor for sorting recycled plastic waste’
- ↑ Iñigo Vegas, Kris Broos, Peter Nielsen, Oliver Lambertz, Amaia Lisbona, Upgrading the quality of mixed recycled aggregates from construction and demolition waste by using near-infrared sorting technology, Construction and Building Materials, Volume 75, 2015, Pages 121-128, ISSN 0950-0618, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.conbuildmat.2014.09.109.
- ↑ Offer Rozenstein, Eldon Puckrin, Jan Adamowski, Development of a new approach based on midwave infrared spectroscopy for post-consumer black plastic waste sorting in the recycling industry, Waste Management, Volume 68, 2017, Pages 38-44, ISSN 0956-053X, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.wasman.2017.07.023.
- ↑ A. C. Karaca, A. Ertürk, M. K. Güllü, M. Elmas and S. Ertürk, "Automatic waste sorting using shortwave infrared hyperspectral imaging system," 2013 5th Workshop on Hyperspectral Image and Signal Processing: Evolution in Remote Sensing (WHISPERS), Gainesville, FL, 2013, pp. 1-4. doi: 10.1109/WHISPERS.2013.8080744
- ↑ Masanori Kumagai, Hideto Suyama, Tomoaki Sato, Toshio Amano, and Nobuaki Ogawa, "Discrimination of Plastics Using a Portable near Infrared Spectrometer," J. Near Infrared Spectrosc. 10, 247-255 (2002)
- ↑ Kyle Eubanks, Sorting Through Sorters: Your Guide to Sortation Conveyor. Bastian Solutions. Date accessed: 2020-02-08 https://www.bastiansolutions.com/blog/sorting-through-sorters-your-guide-to-sortation-conveyor/