PRE2019 3 Group9
Group members
| Name | Study | Student Number |
|---|---|---|
| Nick Reniers | Technische Wiskunde | 1258362 |
| Jankatiri Boon | Werktuigbouwkunde | 1003254 |
| Milan Hutten | Software Science | 0997241 |
| Mendel van der Vleuten | Technische Wiskunde | 1262564 |
| Ferenc Sterkens | Werktuigbouwkunde | 1022090 |
Introduction
Problem statement
Animal researchers are unable to effectively gather data of subterranean species without destroying their burrows or tunnel systems.
Users
Researchers of subterranean animals or underground tunnel systems
User Needs
The following list of user needs does not focus on any particular type of researcher or animal species yet and thus requires modification
- Observe animals within their burrows
- Visualize burrows
- Keep track of population growth
- Safely (both for the researcher and the animal) extract animal from their burrow
Animal Needs
The following list of user needs does not focus on any particular animal species yet and thus requires modification
- Be disturbed as little as possible (May require more elaborate description)
Biological study fields
This list is composed purely based on the short descriptions of the studies.
- Ethology: the study of the behaviour of animals. Requires ability to observe individuals.
- Entomolgy, Herpetology, Ichtyology, Mammalogy and Ornithology: the studies of insects, reptiles and amphibians, fish, mammals and birds respectively. Purely based on the species we focus on.
- Biogeograph: the study of the distribution of species spatially and temporally. Requires ability to observe individuals and count populations.
- Biomechanics: the study of the mechanics of living beings. Requires ability to observe individuals. Specifically interesting for mechanics that do not or rarely occur above ground.
- Chronobiology: the study of periodic events in living systems. Requires ability to observe individuals
- Conservation biology: the study of the preservation, protection, or restoration of the natural environment, natural ecosystems, vegetation, and wildlife. Requires ability to count populations.
- Ecology: the study of the interactions of living organisms with one another and with the non-living elements of their environment. Requires ability to observe individuals.
- Sociobiology: the study of social behavior in terms of evolution. Requires ability to observe individuals.
Requirements
The robot should be able to:
- Safely and autonomously navigate the specified underground systems
- Map these systems adequately
- Be able to return to the user after completing its tasks
Approach
We approach the problem in a very practical manner, we opt to create a robot that autonomously investigates underground tunnels and maps them. We first make a selection of subterranean animals for which we can map their corresponding burrows, and then research details of these animals and underground systems as to prepare a robot that can safely navigate them
Objectives and milestones
- Make a selection of animals for which it is feasible to construct a robot that navigates their burrows
- Research the animals specified in the first milestone and their corresponding underground systems
- Make a construction plan for a robot that could navigate said tunnels adequately
- Prepare software for path finding in burrowss
- Prepare software for mapping the underground systems
- Construct the robot
- Validate the workings of the robot and summarize our findings
Task division
State-of-the-art
A robotics-oriented taxonomy of how ethologists characterize the traversability of animal environments surveys 21 studies of how ethologists characterize the environments through which animals traverse and groups the found characteristics into three broad catergories: local navigational constraints, surface properties, and global layout properties. From these the article makes four recommendations to aid roboticists in selecting a suitable robot for particular environments, building testbeds for the testing and comparing of robots and the collection of data about an environment.
Burrowing rescue robot referring to a mole's shoveling motion proposes an novel inspecting robot designed to inspect survivors at landslide disaster sites. Its proposed propulsion method is inspired by the shoveling motion of a mole.
Deformable Octahedron Burrowing Robot explores the use of a deformable octahedron robot for the autonomous exploration of complex confined spaces. Unlike most other robots, it is able to adapt its shape to better traverse intricate sections of cavities.
Soft Robotic Burrowing Device with Tip-Extension and Granular Fluidization proposes a soft robotic device that burrows through dry sand, leveraging the principles of both tip-extension and granular fluidization.
A Remote Operated Multi-Tracked Vehicle for Subterranean Exploration of Gopher Tortoise Burrows discusses a topic closely related to the one discussed on this page. This article describes a remotely operated vehicle designed to survey and investigate gopher turtoise burrows for the estimation of populations.
CRABOT: A Biomimetic Burrowing Robot Designed for Underground Chemical Source Location describes a prototype burrowing robot called CRABOT developed to help find leaks in undergroud piplines transporting chemicals.
Cockroaches traverse crevices, crawl rapidly in confined spaces, and inspire a soft, legged robot explains how cockroaches way of traversing small crevices support a model of a new unexplored mode of locomotion "body-friction legged crawling" which could be applied in robotics.
Towards a Mobile Mapping Robot for Underground Mines describes a robot platform which can help construct 3D environment underground mappings.
Development of Search-and-rescue Robots for Underground Coal Mine Applications describes the design and development of a coal mine rescue robot which can be used as a reference.
Autonomous Robotic Monitoring of Underground Cable Systems investigates the possibility of autonomous robotic mobile platforms for monitoring infrastructures
PATH FINDING - Dijkstra’s and A* Algorithm’s summarizes and elaborates on famous path finding algorithms
A shortest-path algorithm for solving the fleet management problem in underground mines uses a shortest path algorithm to manage and schedule underground infrastructure
A Robotic System for Underground Coal Mining "describes a system that automates a continuous miner, enabling it to maneuver in highly constrained environments..."
An underground explorer robot based on peristaltic crawling of earthworms takes inspiration from the earthworm to develop a robot that uses peristaltic crawling which is useful for underground exploration
Evolving Sparse Direction Maps for Maze Pathfinding This paper focuses on evolving data that allows an entity to reach a point quickly from any other point in the maze. This kind of map is generated by a simple genetic algorithm. But this method did not necessarily give the shortest path.
View-Based Cognitive Mapping and Path Planning A view graph is created where views are seen as nodes and the movement between views are seen as edges. This graph retains the topological and directional structure of the maze. A neural network can learn the view graph during a random exploration which then allows it to generate expectations about which views will be encountered next.
Design and Implementation of a Path Finding Robot Using Flood Fill Algorithm This article tries to find out how effective the flood fill algorithm is for maze solving. This algorithm was implemented in a small robot with ultrasonic range sensor and wheel rotation decoders. The robot was able to map the maze and afterwards would do a second run where it tried to find a shortest route to the goal.
Portal-Based True-Distance Heuristics for Path Finding This article introduces a new true distance memory based heuristics as a way to obtain admissible heuristics for explicit stat spaces.
Micromouse : Maze solving algorithm This article is about the creation of a small scale robot which navigates a maze based on sensors, the algorithm used was based on the bellman flooding algorithm with a maze consisting of 16x16 cells.
Path finding simulator for mobile robot navigation This paper is focused on creating a path finding simulator for pioneer 3dx mobile robot. The simulator is provided with multiple algorithms, it can then use any or multiple them (with comparison) to find the shortest possible route.
Solving a Reconfigurable Maze using Hybrid Wall Follower Algorithm This paper expands on the wall follower method of solving a maze, the new algorithm combines left and right hand rules and tests them on several mazes. This hybrid algorithm improved the maze solving abilities significantly compared to just following the wall.
G. Kouros, I. Kostavelis, E. Skartados, D. Giakoumis, A. Simi, G. Manacorda, D. Tzovaras, 3D Underground Mapping with a Mobile Robot and a GPR Antenna, 2018 IEEE/RSJ International Conference on Intelligent Robots and Systems (IROS 2018), Madrid, Spain, October 2018
This paper focuses on scanning subsurface environments using a GPR antenna. This information is then used to create a 3D model of the system.
Kevin James Worrall, David Firstbrook, Thaleia Flessa, Euan McGookin, Douglas Thomson, Patrick Harkness, “Modelling and Control of a Biologically Inspired Trenchless Drilling Device”, in The 12th International UKACC Conference on Control, Sheffield, UK, 5-7 Sept 2018 This work presents the methods used and initial findings of the control of the model for an autonomous trenchless drilling device, with bioinspired worm-like locomotion. The model is validated using Inverse Simulation. The initial control is detailed with data from the simulation and experimental device.
G. Kouros, C. Psarras, I. Kostavelis, D. Giakoumis, D. Tzovaras, Surface/Subsurface Mapping with an Integrated Rover-GPR System, A Simulation Approach, IEEE International Conference on Simulation, Modeling and Programming for Autonomous Robots (SIMPAR 2018), Brisbane, Australia, May 2018. This paper further focuses on the GPR antenna robot, only this time it has an intregrated antenna which allows it to seamlessly integrated to build adjunct surface and subsurface maps.
A. Simi, D. Pasculli, G. Manacorda, “Badger project: GPR system design on board on a underground drilling robot”, 10th International Workshop on Advanced Ground Penetrating Radar (IWAGPR 2019), Hague, The Netherlands, Sep 2019 The present paper presents some results of EU founded project called Badger, the first underground robotic system that can drill, maneuver, localize, map and navigate in the underground space, and which will be equipped with tools for constructing complex geometry networks of stable boreholes.
Effort Table
Week 1
| Name | Total | Break-down | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nick Reniers | 7 hours | Introduction lecture (2h), Meeting discussing subject (2h), Studying papers and editing wiki(3h) | |
| Jankatiri Boon | 6 hours | Introduction lecture (2h), Meeting discussing subject (2h), Studied papers and editing wiki (2h) | |
| Milan Hutten | 7.5 hours | Introduction lecture (2h), Meeting discussing subject (2h), Studied papers (3.5h) | |
| Mendel van der Vleuten | 8 hours | introduction lecture (2h), small scale test code (2h), meeting discussed subject (1,5h), studying papers (2,5h) | |
| Ferenc Sterkens | 6 hours | introduction lecture (2h), Meeting discussed subject (2h), reading some papers (1h), making planning (1h) |
Week 2
| Name | Total | Break-down | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nick Reniers | 5 hours | Tutor meeting (20m), Group meeting (40m), recapping graph theory (2h), searching suitable algorithms and writing them (2h) | |
| Jankatiri Boon | 5.5 hours | Exploring and reading literature (3h), setup society and enterprise list (1h), write society and enterprise analysis (1.5h) | |
| Milan Hutten | 6.25 hours | Tutor meeting (20m), Group meeting (40m), Composing biological study list (30m), Looking for Interview Candidates (4.5h), Composing list of user needs and animal needs (15m) | |
| Mendel van der Vleuten | 5 hours | Tutor meeting (20m), Group meeting (40m), Exploritory literature research (2h), Studying papers of robots (2h) | |
| Ferenc Sterkens | 5 hours | tutor meeting (20), Group meeting (40m), Looking for interview candidates (3h), mailing candidates (1h) |
Week 3
| Name | Total | Break-down | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nick Reniers | |||
| Jankatiri Boon | |||
| Milan Hutten | Tutor meeting (20m), Group meeting (10m), Research into mapping out the burrows (5.5h) | ||
| Mendel van der Vleuten | |||
| Ferenc Sterkens | tutor meeting (20m), group meeting (10m), |
Interview Candidates
prof.dr.ir F (Frank) van Langevelde has only 3 publications related to soil fauna. In these studies, they mainly refer with "soil fauna" to smaller critters such as nematodes, collembola (springtails) and other small arthropods inhabiting the soil. Most of which either do not create burrows but just tunnels through moving around in the soil. Their sampling of soil fauna can be oversimplified as extracting samples from the natural environment, extracting the desired type of animal from those samples, for example extracting collembola using tullgren funnels, and doing the required measurements. Because most species do not create burrows and because of the effectiveness of the current sampling strategy, the use of robots in this scenario does not seem to be a viable option.
- Van Langevelde, F., V. Comor, S. de Bie, H.H.T. Prins and M.P. Thakur (2020) Disturbance regulates the density – body mass relationship of soil fauna. Ecological Applications 30:e02019
- Thakur, M.P., M.P. Berg, N. Eisenhauer and F. van Langevelde (2014) Disturbance–diversity relationships for soil fauna are explained by faunal community biomass in a salt marsh. Soil Biology & Biochemistry 78:30–37
- Comor, V., M.P. Thakur, M.P. Berg, S. de Bie, H.H.T. Prins and F. van Langevelde (2014) Productivity affects the density – body mass relationship of soil fauna communities. Soil Biology & Biochemistry 72:203–211
dr.ir. AR (Anouschka) Hof has mostly done studies into the decline of the western hedgehogs pupulations in europe, and mainly in Great Britain, when it comes to soil fauna. This makes her an interesting candidate, though there are two things to consider. First, she seems to mostly get data via questionaires rather than field study. Just like with the sampling of the soil fauna done by Langevelde, the questionaire might be more effective then using robots. Secondly, a hedgehogs den is not very complex, and not even always underground, making pathfinding not a big priority. If a robot would be used, a remote controlled one would probably easily suffice.
- The impact of grassy field margins on macro-invertebrate abundance in adjacent arable fields
- A study of the current status of the hedgehog (Erinaceus europaeus), and its decline in Great Britain since 1960
- The value of green-spaces in built-up areas for western hedgehogs
- Quantifying the long-term decline of the West European hedgehog in England by subsampling citizen-science datasets
- Factors affecting hedgehog presence on farmland as assessed by a questionnaire survey
- European terrestrial gastropod distribution. How may climate change affect their diversity and current distribution
- Investigating the role of the eurasian badger (Meles meles) in the nationwide distribution of the western european hedgehog (Erinaceus europaeus) in England
- Local variations in small scale movements of hedgehogs in rural areas.
- Egels in de problemen?
Y (Yorick) Liefting BSc is not a biological scientist himself, but he experiments with new technology and develops tools to support research.
Path finding
Given that we want to map underground tunnels of a specific species of subterranean animals, we need a systematic and preferably mathematically adequate way to represent different important aspects of the tunnels. The most straightforward way to do this is by the usage of the mathematical objects that are graphs. A graph G is a tuple G=(V,E) consisting of a vertex set V and an edge set E. Here, the edge set E contains unordered pairs of vertices between which an edge is present. There is also a variant of graphs in which the vertex pairs are ordered, but for the purpose of tunnel mapping, this is inconvenient. We can also consider the concept of a multigraph, in which multiple edges are possible between the same two vertices, this may be the case for some certain species of animals, but this demands further research. For now, we will assume simple undirected graphs as representatives for the tunnels of our species of animals.
For the purpose of mapping an underground tunnel system in general, one can deploy a multitude of graph algorithms. The most obvious algorithms for this purpose are depth first search and breadth first search, which greedily traverse a graph (representing the underground system of the animal). We can also look into finding specific points of interest depending on the animals we want to investigate. For example, one may be particularly interested in finding a nest in a mole underground system. For such purposes, specialized search algorithms that take into account the known properties of such points of interest, may be optimal.
Given that we have found the graph corresponding to the subterranean structure we want to investigate, we can look at some interesting properties of the graph. Examples would be the minimum spanning tree of the graph or the (non-)existence of cycles and connectedness.
When talking about path finding in robots it is also necessary to think of ways for the robot to follow a path. Considering we will be working underground and partially above ground in places made constructed by animals, it would be a good idea to look into how these animals move or to inspire the movement of the robot on biological movement. In the paper "Biologically Inspired Locomotion Strategies: Novel Ground Mobile Robots at RoMeLa" a few designs are discussed on moving forward on land. The first robot is a concept that is closely related to tracks. This design is inspired on single celled organisms such as amoeba. An elongated torus continuously rolls such that there is a system similar to 360 degree track system. This could be very useful for our goals, but difficulties will lie in gathering and collecting data. The second design involves a robot with 3 legs, This design makes use of a swinging third legs, so it needs a lot of space. This is not something which would be useful for underground or small above ground burrows/nests. The robot MARS utilizes six axi-symmetrically arranged limbs, this robot is well adapted for crawling over uneven terrain, which is what we are interested in. But it does not perform well in tunnel systems. It also uses gecko-like dry adhesive to stick to surfaces, but as we are not dealing zero gravity this will most likely not be necessary. So depending on what our final goal is this robot may or may not be of interest. The IMPASS robot has wheels like structures to move forward, it has 6 spokes with small foot like platforms so it can roll. The thing that makes this robot stand out is that the spokes can change in length allowing for better traversing of rough terrain and more stability. Again this robot seems very adept at walking on ground, but less so underground. Finally a humanoid robot is presented but this is very impractical for our goals.
Prairie dogs
Prairie dogs are herbivorous rodents that create interesting burrows. They are native to the grasslands of North America. There are five species of prairie dogs: black-tailed, white-tailed, Gunnison's , Utah, and Mexican prairie dogs.
Black-tailed prairie dogs
Description
Usually, black-tailed prairie dogs have a body that is 36 to 43 centimeters tall and weighs roughly 700 to 1500 grams, where the males tend to be heavier than the females. Their bodies are also very compact, and they have black long claws that are used for digging. The black tailed prairie dogs are usually colored a pale tone of brown, with a black spots on their tail. These points of information may be useful for letting our robot recognize the animals when exploring their burrows, alternatively we may use heat sensors to detect living beings.
Social life and habits
Black-tailed prairie dogs live in prairies of western North America. An image of their geographical distribution is shown below:
The species is also very colonial, colonies of the black-tailed prairie dogs may contain thousands of members, their territory stretching out kilometers in all directions. Colonies are further subdivided in a couple of wards that are based around topographic features such as hills. These ward themselves can then be subdivided into coteries. These coteries consist of groups of one or two men with a number of women and their offspring.
Black-tailed prairie dogs are also diurnal, meaning that they are typically active during daytime. As such, their foraging tends to happen from dawn to dusk. During winter, they do not hibernate and continue to forage. At night however, they go in a state of torpor which is similar to hibernation but shorter and involuntary.
Burrows
Burrows are underground tunnels that have at least one opening at the surface. Prairie dog burrows are essential to defend the species against predators and weather circumstances. The diameter of such a burrow is usually around 10-30cm at the surface and a little bit more narrow underground. The depth of these burrows is generally around 2-3 meters with a length of 5 to 10 meters, but they can range to 33 meters long and 10 meters deep. Burrows for raising the young, nursery burrows and burrows for submergence at sunset, contain one or two nest chambers that are filled with dry grass.
Bronnen:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prairie_dog (eerste deeltje) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black-tailed_prairie_dog https://books.google.nl/books?hl=nl&lr=&id=BJzzQXkka54C&oi=fnd&pg=PR13&dq=prairie+dog&ots=V21MgOvPXy&sig=bmR17lWn7fuCwlca53E9aXoREQY#v=onepage&q&f=false (black-tailed prairie dog)
Mapping
The robot needs to map out the burrows to improve their navigation. On top of that those maps could be analyzed for research purposes. Ferenc is looking into which sensor are required for mapping among other things and Mendel, Nick and Milan look into how the burrows can best be "visualized" for the robot navigation as well for analysis.
We first had a look at the slides of week 2 of the course Interaction with social robots (0LSUD0) where robot navigation is discussed. Mapping, among other topics, are brought up in the slides. According to the slides, there are three ways to represent an environment. These are using a continuous metric, a discrete metric and discrete topological. In a continuous metric, the world is described using coordinates (x and y) and angles (θ). In a discrete metric, the world is described along a grid. Exact angles are mostly lost, but relative positioning between locations and distances are mostly retained. In discrete topological only relative positioning between locations are retained.
The slides discuss two problems with map building, these are keeping track of changes in the environment and the representation and reduction of uncertainty of the robot. The latter is a general problem with robot navigation, but the first is of greater interest to us. Prairie dogs change their burrows over time, for example to accomodate more of them. This is a problem the robot is more likely to run into if it repeatedly has to explore the same burrow. On top of that, if the robot cannot tell the difference between the walls of the tunnels and the prairie dogs, then they will perceive them to be part of the burrow. Then when the prairie dogs move, which they will inevitably do, the burrow will seem to have changed from the robots perspective.
brainstorming
mapping with the assumption that no animals are inside the burrow -there is a problem with this assumption: what if there are animals? --we can deal with that issue by installing some kind of detection system that is able to recognize whether what is detected is an animal or the wall of a tunnel in the burrow. ---one option for this is a heat sensor
what if an animal is diseased?
maybe attach a motion sensing robot
what if a prairy dog is diseased and the robot passes by, what will the other prairy dogs do?
Sources
Thrun, S. (2002). Robotic mapping: A survey. Exploring artificial intelligence in the new millennium, 1(1-35), 1. Thrun, S., Hahnel, D., Ferguson, D., Montemerlo, M., Triebel, R., Burgard, W., ... & Whittaker, W. (2003, September). A system for volumetric robotic mapping of abandoned mines. In 2003 IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation (Cat. No. 03CH37422) (Vol. 3, pp. 4270-4275). IEEE. Thrun, S. (2002). Probabilistic robotics. Communications of the ACM, 45(3), 52-57. Stachniss, C. (2009). Robotic mapping and exploration (Vol. 55). Springer. Karlsson, L. N., Pirjanian, P., Goncalves, L. F. D., & Di Bernardo, E. (2006). U.S. Patent No. 7,015,831. Washington, DC: U.S. Patent and Trademark Office. Thrun, S., Thayer, S., Whittaker, W., Baker, C., Burgard, W., Ferguson, D., ... & Reverte, C. (2004). Autonomous exploration and mapping of abandoned mines. IEEE Robotics & Automation Magazine, 11(4), 79-91.
Mechanics
To have a working robot, the mechanical parts and sensors are the most important and essential part of the robot. Without these the robot is rendered useless. The different parts also have to be chosen wisely as they need to be just right for the robot. For example the sensors need to be not only precise but also resistant to dirt and other small obstacles and the wheels need to be big enough for the terrain but small enough to maneuver.
To start off we will make a general overview of all the parts such a robot should have, and after deciding on a design, another list with the specific parts will be made. The robot should have wheels and a way to accelerate the wheels, which is possible with either multiple motors or with a central motor and a drive shaft. The robot should also have tires or spikes so that it has enough grip to move forward. The steering of the front shaft should also be possible in the robot, else we would have a problem at corners.