Revision as of 11:47, 19 March 2023

MAIL

Dear team,

Group 8:

Fee Noordermeer (1587404) - [[1]]

Matthieu den Otter (0333626) – [[2]]

Merel Nienhuis (1721763) - [[3]]

Sam Lancee (1640364) - [[4]]

Wilco van der Veen (1021299) - [[5]] Automotive Technology

Dave Hannet (1715666)

Subject: A wearable device for people with problems remembering names (mild dementia, temporal or permanent memory loss or just bad memory) that recognizes a face and gives the user a corresponding name via a Bluetooth connect earplug (possibly hearing device).

Special request: one of our team members has classes during hr 1-2 on monday. Is it possible to arrange a meeting during hr 3 or 4?

Kind regards, group 8

Fee Noordermeer, Matthieu den Otter, Merel Nienhuis, Sam Lancee and Wilco van der Veen

Problem statement

Objective

Who are the user?

The user consists of people that have problems with memory loss. This is typically a group of people of older age. The group consists of for example people with dementia.

What do they require?

Approach

Milestones

Deliverables

Who’s doing what?

- hardware (Wilco)

- software (Mathieu, Merel, Sam)

facial recognition
Audio
Data base

- User writing part (Merel, Sam)

-

State of the Art (25 articles)

Sam

1 https://dl.acm.org/doi/abs/10.1145/1090785.1090806?casa_token=M2Z7T1CRUDAAAAAA:OTdONvxGmFEzED-EVnPLnwj3W6lwWpdxyHNIHEX9YsEzU3mSZbWlq99lttpeHd4piY9kanAwNNJ4 --> pretty much what we plan on doing, but for people with visual impairments.

2 https://dl.acm.org/doi/abs/10.1145/2459236.2459262?casa_token=ujZ8wpZTorkAAAAA:WDsDXJZZCHIuySAv53DFSyvW5xGCtSdaq8riNw07sxXSfXgo8CjtEjNuURSYpaDu6vGnEVOlw4I8 --> what we are doing but for a different user group

3 https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-3-319-16634-6_31 --> facial recognition in your glasses, with user interface desplay

4 https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-3-319-92384-0_11 --> wearables and security/privacy problems

5 https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/pdf/10.1177/1533317519883493 --> looking at the acceptence of using wearables for person with dementia, from caregiver view

Wilco

1 https://ojs.wiserpub.com/index.php/AIE/article/view/62/328 --> An Innovative Approach for Face Recognition Using Raspberry Pi

2 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3513528 --> Data Protection Challenges in the Internet of Things Era: An Assessment of Protection Offered by PDPA 2010

3 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0747563217304284 --> Consumer adaptation and infusion of wearable devices for healthcare

4 https://academic.oup.com/ageing/article/30/6/455/39799?login=true --> Assistive technology in elderly care

5 https://www.mdpi.com/1648-9144/56/6/257 --> Stress in the Volunteer Caregiver: Human-Centric Technology Can Support Both Caregivers and People with Dementia

Merel

1 https://www.faceblind.org/research/ --> what is prosopagnosia (official name for having problems with recognizing faces) + interesting sentence for our project: " It is important to note that prosopagnosia is defined by problems recognizing faces, not recalling names. "

2 https://www.cbc.ca/documentaries/the-nature-of-things/this-woman-can-t-recognize-her-own-daughter-s-face-but-technology-is-helping-her-1.6312174 --> zelfde maar dan met app op telefoon

3 https://www.researchgate.net/publication/263091789_A_room_full_of_strangers_every_day_The_psychosocial_impact_of_developmental_prosopagnosia_on_children_and_their_families --> impact on families, important to manage to help them with face recognition difficulties

4 https://courses.engr.illinois.edu/ece445/getfile.asp?id=12216 --> requirements for device that is similar to our idea

5 http://wearcam.org/smc2020/IEEE_SMC2020_0700_prosopagnosia.pdf --> glasses, but also proof that participants have shown improvements after using glasses

Matthieu

1 https://www.orcam.com/en/myeye2/#:~:text=OrCam%20MyEye%20is%20a%20revolutionary,live%20a%20more%20independent%20life! Currently existing device that does all and more, but high costs

2 https://nitratine.net/blog/post/python-face-recognition-tutorial/ Face recognition with python

3 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0197457214001360?via%3Dihub Maybe useful to set gradations in dementia

4 https://dl.acm.org/doi/pdf/10.1145/3351248 Face Recognition Assistant for People with Visual Impairments

5 https://aging.jmir.org/2019/1/e13378/PDFA Web-Based Mobile App With a Smartwatch to Support Social Engagement in Persons With Memory Loss: Pilot Randomized Controlled Trial

Fee

1 Support vector machines for face recognition

2 Training Support Vector Machines: an Application to Face Detection

3 Robust face detection using local CNN and SVM based on kernel combination

4 Computationally Efficient Face Detection

5 Support vector machine based multi-view face detection and recognition

Summaries articles 0LAUK0 Merel

Article 1

https://www.faceblind.org/research/

Understanding Prosopagnosia

People who suffer from prosopagnosia have difficulties with the recognition of facial identity. This can create social problems. Prosopagnosics do not have problems with recalling names.

It is possible that prosopagnosia occurs after brain damage due to trauma, stroke or a disease. Sometimes, it is the case that this impairment has always been there for someone.

Article 2

https://www.cbc.ca/documentaries/the-nature-of-things/this-woman-can-t-recognize-her-own-daughter-s-face-but-technology-is-helping-her-1.6312174

This woman can't recognize her own daughter's face, but technology is helping her

This article is about a woman that is not able to recognize faces, but technology does help her.

The woman tells that her inability to recognize faces can cause issues. She feels insecure and people are hurt that she does not recognize them. She does recognize voices and other things like birthmarks. Sometimes she does not even recognize herself.

A personalize app was developed for her to help her recognize people. People stand on the opposite of the phone, the camera scans the face and gives the name which can be seen by the woman.

The reactions are positive, for the woman with prosopagnosia but also for her close ones. They are delighted that the woman did recognize her with the help of the phone. The woman felt sure which felt good for her, it was not just a guess. However, the woman was not pleased about the fact that she had to look at the phone the whole time to be able to recognize someone.

Article 3

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/263091789_A_room_full_of_strangers_every_day_The_psychosocial_impact_of_developmental_prosopagnosia_on_children_and_their_families

“A room full of strangers every day”: The psychosocial impact of developmental prosopagnosia on children and their families

Individuals with developmental prosopagnosia have severe face recognition difficulties due to a failure to develop the necessary visual mechanisms for recognizing faces. These difficulties occur in the absence of brain damage and despite normal low-level vision and intellect. Adults with developmental prosopagnosia report serious personal and emotional consequences from their inability to recognize faces, but little is known about the psychosocial consequences in childhood. Given the importance of face recognition in daily life, and the potential for unique social consequences of impaired face recognition in childhood, we sought to evaluate the impact of developmental prosopagnosia on children and their families. We conducted interviews with 8 children with developmental prosopagnosia and their parents. A battery of face recognition tests was used to confirm the face recognition impairment reported by the parents of each child. We used thematic analysis to develop common themes among the psychosocial experiences of children with developmental prosopagnosia and their parents. Our findings indicate a need for increased awareness and treatment of developmental prosopagnosia to help these children manage their face recognition difficulties and to promote their social and emotional wellbeing.

Article 4

https://courses.engr.illinois.edu/ece445/getfile.asp?id=12216

Assistive Technology for Patients with Medical Face Blindness

This article gives an overview of requirements and verification for a device that assists social interaction for individuals with prosopagnosia. It also states that it is important to follow the IEEE Code of ethics and to develop something that is aware of potential safety-related issues.

Article 5

http://wearcam.org/smc2020/IEEE_SMC2020_0700_prosopagnosia.pdf

Face Recognition and Rehabilitation: A Wearable Assistive and Training System for Prosopagnosia

The design and implementation of an integrated wearable face recognition and training system for prosopagnosia patients are presented. The purpose of this assistive technology is to provide real-time memory assistance and long-term rehabilitation. The real-time face recognition mode provides audio and visual notification of people who interact with the subject, while the at-home training mode combines features of mnemonic and perceptual training to help with prosopagnosia rehabilitation. In addition, a custom eye tracker is developed to determine the person whom the subject is making eye contact with within a crowd. Using the inverted face effect to mimic the difficulties of prosopagnosia patients, clinically healthy participants have shown improvements in their face-naming abilities. Early results indicate the system’s potential to enrich the well-being of prosopagnosia patients.

Summaries articles 0LAUK0 Matthieu

Article 1 https://www.orcam.com/en/myeye2/#:~:text=OrCam%20MyEye%20is%20a%20revolutionary,live%20a%20more%20independent%20life!

OrCam MyEye is a voice activated device that attaches to virtually any glasses. It can instantly read to you text from a book, smartphone screen or any other surface, recognize faces, help you shop on your own, work more efficiently, and live a more independent life! OrCam MyEye conveys visual information audibly, in real-time and offline. COST: >3000 euros at lowvisionshop.nl

Article 2 https://nitratine.net/blog/post/python-face-recognition-tutorial/

Using the face_recognition for detecting and matching a face

Article 3 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0197457214001360?via%3Dihub

Dementia can be divided in stages. These can be useful to specify target group for device

Article 4 https://dl.acm.org/doi/pdf/10.1145/3351248 Face Recognition Assistant for People with Visual Impairments

Gives interesting background for investigating the requirements and challenges that must be addressed in the design of a face recognition system for helping VIPs recognize people with whom they have weak-ties
Article 5 https://aging.jmir.org/2019/1/e13378/PDFA Web-Based Mobile App With a Smartwatch to Support Social Engagement in Persons With Memory Loss: Pilot Randomized Controlled Trial

The Social Support Aid (SSA) App on mobile phone: Reasons why presented technology was not usefull: (1) complexity of the SSA, (2) enrollment process, (3) impracticality, (4) stigma, and (5) functionality of the SSA.

Summary articles Sam

Article 1

A wearable face recognition system for individuals with visual impairments

Icare interaction assistant which is there for helping with social interactions for people who are visually impaired. Talks about the problems with using real-time facial recognition for a wearable device. This device is their to see what the other person for facial expressions has.

Article 2

Who are you?: A wearable face recognition system to support human memory

In this paper they talk about the use of a wearable that is there to aid human memory. This can be for remembering names of other people. They first deal with different design ideas and after that a face recognition approach.

Article 3

A Wearable Face Recognition System on Google Glass for Assisting Social Interactions

They present a face recognition on Google Glass that is there to help with face detection, eye localization, face recognition and comes with a user interface for information display. Multiple methods are used to see which works better for localizing the eyes and different lighting conditions.

Article 4

Wearables Security and Privacy

Wearable devices are currently in many different applications in health care. Since these applications are relatively new there is little experience with security and privacy. It ends with the conclusion that before these wearables are for open market the security and privacy issues should be worked out.

Article 5

Facotrs Affecting Caregivers' Acceptance of the use of wearable devices by patiens with dementia: an extension of the unified theory of acceptance and use of technology model

Using a structered online questionnaire it was researched if caregivers will expect the use of wearables for patients with dementia. They constructed a model to see which factors had an influence. The conclusion is that social influence, effeort expectancy, facilitating conditions and behavioral intention all had a great impact on this model. But it was also seen that the technology anxiety and that people tend to have a resistance to chance were both not a predictor for the model.

MoSCoW Analysis

MUST

- have a camera

- be able to be connected to an audio device (ear, headphones, connected by bluetooth, hearingaid)

- maintain a database with Images ('faces') and Audio fragments ('names') [maximum number of entries?]

- operations on database: add / delete (not edit)

- have a user button1 to make an image of the person to be recognized, which triggers the recognition and plays the corresponding audio fragment on the ear

- have a button2 to switch on/off

- have a button3 to add an entry to the database (photo + audio)

- be very, very easy to use

SHOULD

- be closed system to protect data

- have a rechargeable battery and a device to charge

- have an indicator for low battery

- a housing to contain the hardware (easy to wear for instance around the neck)

COULD

- have a possibility of changing the audio volume (button4)

- send audio output to hearing device

WONT

- have a display

WEEKLY REPORTS?

W1
Matthieu	Group discussion (2), Study papers (3)	5
Merel
Sam
Fee
Wilco
Dave

Progress Matthieu 6 maart

Ik heb met pyaudio library twee functions gemaakt:

1) Afspelen ingesproken audio fragment na korte spacebar press

2) Opnemen na langere (> halve seconde) op spacebar press

Opnemen maakt een wav file aan ('test.wav'). Ditzelfde fragment wordt afgespeeld.

Het is erg lastig om inspreken tijdens button press te realiseren, maar uiteindelijk zal dat wel lukken.

De uitdaging ligt er nu in om de boel op raspberry te krijgen en te koppelen met een oorttje. Ik heb raspberry besteld. Die krijg ik vandaag wss binnen.

12 March

Test environment complete: microphone, camera and ears on raspberry.

We got two working environments for audio and video part. This monday we will try to connect the two and make ik run on Raspberry.

WhatsApp Image 2023-03-12 at 13.21.01.jpg

Progress Sam

I worked on the recognizing face part of the software. Currently all the needed libraries are imported. I use the OpenCv and the facial_recognition libraries. With those libraries and LBPHFaceRecognizer provided from the OpenCv the facial recognition works. The current state is that the person needs to add pictures in a folder with a name and in that way the software will recognize the face. For now this is helpfull, but this needs to change from adding by the means of a folder, to adding by holding the button. And for the name instead of naming the folder it should use an audio part that the user itself gives. The following image can be obtained while using the webcam. (can someone help with the placement because this looks badd)

As you can see when a face is detected it will but a rectangle around that person. If the person is already added manually to the database it will present the name, in this case "Sam Lancee". When the person is not detected the label will say "unkown person".

Progress Matthieu & Sam 20-3-23

We focused on working together to implement both codes. It can now record an audio fragment and take a picture of the person that is in front of the camera by pressing the button for a couple of seconds and then it put them both in the same folder. After this the user can immediately press the buton once to detect the face and once the face is detected it will play the audio corresponding to that person.

Progress Matthieu 19-3

Got the system working on laptop. Flow between different modes or repetition of same mode is not fine yet!

While key pressed an audio is recorded (after a delay of 0.5 seconds)

If the key is released after the delay period (ie short press) the recognition is started. The systems recognizes 50-60% of the faces.

PROBLEM FOR NOW: implementation on raspberry. Since there is no keyboard on rasperry, i propose to simulate a key press by a rising GPIO and a key release by falling GPIO (button press)

Progress Dave

Introduction

This report will give a detailed user guide about the invention that will help people with memory loss remember names with the help from a wearable facial recognition scanner. The report will describe in detail why the device is needed in our society, for who the device is, what the exact goal of the device is and how the device works in general.

The user needs/requirements for the device

Nearly everyone has probably experienced the inconvenience of forgetting someone’s name, for most people this is not a severe problem as it does not happen distressingly often, but for over 155 million people in the world who suffer from some kind of form of memory loss [1] this is a serious problem as it can be embarrassing, distressing and often unhandy in formal settings. It could also lead to people being unnecessarily insulted if someone keeps on forgetting their name.

An example of this problem and a perceived solution in society is given now; Elly, a 73 year old woman, living in a retirement home was starting to suffer from dementia, to make things worse she knew it was happening. Every week her grandchildren went to visit her and she started to forget their names, Elly was terribly sad about it and thought to herself: “If only there was a device which would help me remember their names when I see them”

It can clearly be derived from the anecdote stated above that there is a serious need for a device which can help people remember names of loved ones. We will now state the needs/requirements that the device will have to have in a MoSCoW analysis stated below:

MUST

- Have a camera

- Be able to be connected to an audio device (ear, headphones, connected by Bluetooth, hearing aid)

- Maintain a database with Images ('faces') and Audio fragments ('names') [maximum number of entries?]

- Operations on database: add / delete (not edit)

- Have a user button1 to make an image of the person to be recognized, which triggers the recognition and plays the corresponding audio fragment on the ear

- Have a button2 to switch on/off

- Have a button3 to add an entry to the database (photo + audio)

- Be easy to use

SHOULD

- Be closed system to protect data

- Have a rechargeable battery and a device to charge

- Have an indicator for low battery

- A housing to contain the hardware (easy to wear for instance around the neck)

COULD

- Have a possibility of changing the audio volume (button4)

- Send audio output to hearing device

- Be waterproof

WON’T

- Have a display

- Be self-sustainable

The user group defined

The user group for the name remembering aid is huge, as stated above over 155 million people suffer from some kind of memory loss which makes it harder to remember names [1]. Some research even points out that nearly 9 out of 10 people sometimes have difficulties remembering the name of someone they met recently, that accounts to nearly 7.2 billion people! The device will be priced at a low price making it accessible for pretty much anyone who feels that forgetting people’s names is a problem they feel needs resolving. The device will be made as small and convenient as possible, so that it will be very user friendly to as many people as possible.

The target user group of the device will now be elaborated on further. When looking at the population of people with memory loss deficiencies the biggest deficiency by far is dementia, with over 55 million people suffering from this disease globally [3]. This target user group was chosen because this is a huge amount of people and a lot of research has been done on dementia, thus making it easier to get an image on how this disease effects its victims and how a device could best help these people.

About 75% of people with dementia are 70 years or older, so the majority of the target user group will be of elderly age, this will be taken into account when designing the device as it will have to be simple in function and also be very clear. Elderly people especially attach a lot of worth to being able to remember their loved ones, making them the best target user group which will benefit the most from the facial recognition device.

The device will be usable in all types of environments, but hospitals and care homes (where people with dementia often reside) will be the prime environment for the device. Because of this the device will be comfortable and easily adjustable, providing extra ease for our selected target user group.

The goal of the device

The main goal of the name remembering aid is simple, help the user remember the name of a person they are meeting in a discreet and quick manner without interrupting the social encounter, this will give the user a relaxed and reassuring feeling which will hopefully improve the ease of their day to day life.

How the device works

How the device works in general will now be explained. The making of a name remembering aid is not simple, the device needs to be small, discreet, accurate, safe and effective all at the same time to be able to serve its goal. The way how the device works is as followed: when you come into contact with someone the device will detect the faces of the people in your proximity, it will also listen to the people who you come into contact with and analyze the their speech searching for key phrases in which the name of the person is disclosed, the device then links the face to the assigned name and then stores this data internally (for privacy reasons). When the user meets the people again the device will recognize the faces and inform the user of the name linked to that face, if the face is new it will also inform the user so that he or she knows that they have never met this person in real life or that they did not state their name.

[1] Alzheimer's Facts and Figures Report | Alzheimer's Association

[2] Is Forgetting Words and Names a Sign of Dementia? - Health News Hub

[3] Dementia (who.int)

[4] What Are the Signs of Alzheimer's Disease? | National Institute on Aging (nih.gov)

Persona: